NASFAA Graduate and Professional Issues Committee Submits Letter to CFPB on Private Loans
Gentlemen and/or Ladies:
As chairpersons of the NASFAA Graduate and Professional Issues Committee (GPIC) and the AAMC Committee on Student Financial Assistance (COSFA), in addition to being financial aid administrators for health professions students, we appreciate the opportunity to provide comments regarding Regulation Z requirements. Although we are in agreement that borrowers need to be adequately informed of their loan rights and responsibilities, mandating this requirement for educational loans provided through the Department of Health and Human Services (Title VII and Title VIII of the PHS) has amassed confusion to the awarding and disbursement process of such loans.
Title VII & Title VIII loans (Health Professions Loan, Nursing Student Loans, Loans for Disadvantaged Students and Primary Care Loans) are subsidized loans funded by the federal government and are similar to the campus-based programs authorized under Title IV of the Higher Education Act, particularly the Federal Perkins Loan. These loans currently have better interest rates and terms than the Federal Direct Stafford and PLUS Loan Programs.
The last Regulation Z final regulations required the completion of the Private Education Loan Application Self-Certification. Under section 1 of the self-certification, the first bullet indicates that lower cost Title IV financial aid may be available. Loans offered under Title VII and VIII are as or more cost effective than loans offered under the Title IV program (particularly the Federal Direct Stafford and Federal Direct PLUS Loans). The third bullet strongly encourages the student to pursue the availability of free or lower-cost financial aid with the school's financial aid office. This statement is confusing since aid administrators are encouraging students to borrow through the more favorable Title VII and Title VIII programs, but still require the completion of the Private Education Loan Applicant Self-Certification. Statements such as these make aid administrators appear to be less knowledgeable and diminish the trusting relationship that aid administrators try to develop with students. In addition, there are most likely several students who are overwhelmed with the paperwork and after reading the Private Education Loan Application Self-Certification become discouraged or believe that Federal Direct Loans are indeed more cost effective.
Institutions are required to award and administer Title VII and Title VIII programs in a fiscal and responsible manner through previous Regulation Z guidance. This guidance provides clear guidelines for awarding, notifying, disbursing and repaying of the aforementioned programs (refer to http://bhpr.hrsa.gov/dsa/sfag/health_professions/bk1prt1.htm). The inclusion of these additional Regulation Z requirements creates an unnecessary paperwork burden for the institution and the student.
The regulations also delay the disbursement of the funds due to the required three day right to cancel option. Depending on a school's institutional policies, the disbursement delay could result in the assessment of late payment charges, removal from classes or delay in living and book reimbursement monies. In addition, Title VII and Title VIII loans have provisions which permit the cancellation without penalty beyond a three day period.
We have spoken to several colleagues who are in agreement with this opinion. Since the regulatory definition for a private education loan was created by the Federal Reserve Board and the CFPB will be responsible for regulation writing henceforth, we request that the CFPB consider eliminating this requirement for Title VII and Title VIII loans offered through the Department of Health and Human Services. If additional authority concerning this matter is required from Congress, we request that appropriate action be taken to provide relief.
Thank you in advance for your consideration.
NASFAA GPIC Chair
Health Sciences Center Financial Aid Office
West Virginia University
AAMC COSFA Chair
Director, Financial Aid Office
- NASFAA Statement on President’s 2014 Budget Request
- WASHINGTON, DC, APRIL 10, 2013 -- In response to President Obama's fiscal year (FY) 2014 budget request, National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators (NASFAA) President Justin Draeger issued the following statement...
- NASFAA Comments on the 2013-14 Draft FAFSA
- In comments submitted to the Department of Education, NASFAA encourages the Department to institute a similar comment process and time-frame for the FAFSA on the Web (FOTW) and highlights challenges the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community faces when completing the FAFSA.
- Higher Education Tax Benefit Testimony Submitted to Senate Finance Committee
- In written testimony submitted to the Senate Committee on Finance, NASFAA joined 11 other higher education organizations to express strong support for extending the American Opportunity Tax Credit, the above-the-line deduction for qualified tuition and related expenses, the Employer-provided Educational Assistance bene...
- NASFAA Signs ACE Letter to Congressional Finance Committees on Extending Education Tax Benefits
- The Senate Finance Committee has reached a tax credit deal that would expand the above-the-line deduction for qualified tuition-related expenses (tuition deduction). NASFAA has joined the American Council on Education (ACE) in expressing strong support for extending the tuition deduction, as well as the AOTC and other ...
- NASFAA Voices Strong Support for CFPB Private Student Loan Recommendations
- National Association of Student Financial AidAdministrators (NASFAA) President Justin Draeger issued the following statement in response to the recommendations put forth by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's (CFPB's) report on private student loans.
- NASFAA Signs Letter Requesting Clarity on 'Principles' for Treatment of Vets
- The American Council on Education (ACE) and the National Association of College and University Business Officers (NACUBO) sent a joint letter signed by NASFAA and 10 other associations to Veterans Affairs (VA), expressing points of confusion with regard to VA's letter to institutions requesting emailed confirmation of ...
- NASFAA Statement on Deal to Temporarily Extend 3.4% Rate on Subsidized Student Loans
- June 27, 2012 -- NASFAA President Justin Draeger issued this statement in response to the proposal to temporarily extend the 3.4 percent rate on subsidized Stafford loans and to permanently limit eligibility for these same subsidized loans to 150 percent of the program length.
- NASFAA Signs ACE and NACUBO Letter to VA on Executive Order
- On Friday, June 22, the American Council on Education (ACE) and the National Association of College and University Business Officers (NACUBO) sent a joint letter signed by NASFAA and 10 other associations to Veterans Affairs (VA), expressing strong belief in the fundamental tenets of the "Principles of Excellence for E...
- Letter to the New York Times Editor
- NASFAA President Justin Dreager sent this letter to the New York Times editor in response to a June 6 editorial.
- NASFAA Comments for Fall 2012 Negotiated Rulemaking
- In preparation for another round of negotiated rulemaking this fall, NASFAA submits its comments on proposals for regulatory action. The Department of Education has suggested establishing or revising regulations to address fraud, disbursement provisions of the cash management regulations and campus-based programs.
- NASFAA Comments on Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) College Cost Comparison Worksheet
- NASFAA appreciates the opportunity to provide comment on the CFPB College Cost Comparison Worksheet. Overall, NASFAA supports the concept of students and families being able to compare postsecondary institutions accurately so that they can be empowered to make informed and responsible decisions about postsecondary educ...
- NASFAA Submits Comments on CFPB’s Financial Aid Comparison Shopper
- NASFAA submitted comments and suggested improvements to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) on its beta version of the "Financial Aid Comparison Shopper," an interactive, online tool designed to help students and families compare the costs of post-secondary education at various institutions. While emphasizi...
- NASFAA Endorses Legislation to Expand Student Loan Interest Deduction
- NASFAA joined five other higher education groups to endorse legislation by Rep. Charles Rangel (D-NY) that would expand the Student Loan Interest Deduction (SLID).
- NASFAA Signs Testimony to Support Extending Higher Education Tax Benefits
- NASFAA joined the higher education community in signing written testimony to Congress to express support for extending higher education tax benefits, including the American Opportunity Tax Credit, set to expire at the end of the year.
- NASFAA Signs Letter to Support Legislation on Interest Rate
- NASFAA joins 40 higher education associations in signing a letter drafted by the American Council on Education to express support for enacting legislation to keep the interest rate on subsidized Stafford loans from doubling -- from 3.4 percent to 6.8 percent -- on July 1. Democrats and Republicans have each proposed le...
- NASFAA Joins Higher Ed Associations in Letter to House on Interest Rate Legislation
- NASFAA joins several other higher education associations in signing a letter drafted by the American Council on Education to the House of Representatives to express support for enacting legislation to keep the interest rate on subsidized Stafford loans from doubling -- from 3.4 percent to 6.8 percent -- on July 1.
- NASFAA Joins NACUBO Effort to Halt Implementation of VA Tuition Offset Policy
- NASFAA joined NACUBO and 12 other higher education associations in signing onto a letter urging the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to halt the reinstatement of a policy that would offset veteran debts against Post-9/11 G.I. Bill tuition and fee payments. Currently, VA can recover a debt owed by a veteran from...
- NASFAA Urges Congress to Allow Private Student Loans to Be Discharged in Bankruptcy
- NASFAA President Justin Draeger submitted this statement in support of legislation that would allow private student loans to be discharged in bankruptcy.
- NASFAA Submits Comments on White House College Scorecard
- As part of his FY 2013 budget request, and a larger college affordability plan, President Obama proposed the creation of a College Scorecard to enable students and families to compare college costs before making a decision on postsecondary education. NASFAA recently submitted comments on a draft Scorecard after the ad...
- NASFAA Urges Action on Student Health Insurance Coverage Regulations
- NASFAA joined the American Council on Education (ACE) and six other associations to urge the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to immediately issue the final version of student health insurance coverage regulations or delayed the regulations until the 2013-14 academic year.
- Higher Ed Groups Urge House to Repeal State Authorization, Definition of Credit Hour
- NASFAA joined 22 higher education groups urging lawmakers in the U.S. House of Representatives to vote for legislation that would repeal the credit hour definition and state authorization regulations that took effect July 1, 2011.
- NASFAA Joins Higher Ed Groups Urging House to Repeal State Authorization, Definition of Credit Hour
- NASFAA joined 22 higher education groups urging lawmakers in the U.S. House of Representatives to vote for legislation that would repeal the credit hour definition and state authorization regulations that took effect July 1, 2011. The House is scheduled to vote on the Protecting Academic Freedom in Higher Education Act...
- NASFAA Letter to ED on 12 Semester Pell Grant Limit
- NASFAA President Justin Draeger urges Education Secretary Duncan to hold schools harmless for any inadvertent Pell Grant overpayments made to students who the Department of Education doesn't properly identify as having reached the new 12 semester Pell limit by the time the grant is disbursed.
- NASFAA Makes Recommendations for FSA’s 5-Year Strategic Plan
- In a letter to the Department of Education, NASFAA stresses the value and function of financial aid administrators (FAAs) as Federal Student Aid (FSA) begins to finalize a Strategic Plan for Fiscal Years 2012-16. In the Jan. 17 letter, NASFAA recommends the Department more clearly define the role of financial aid admin...
- NASFAA Comments on FSA’s 5-Year Strategic Plan
- In a letter to the Department of Education, NASFAA provides comment on the draft Federal Student Aid Strategic Plan for Fiscal Years 2012-16. As the association that represents student aid administrators—those that provide the actual link between the Department of Education and student aid recipients —NASFAA members pr...
- Letter to House Labor-HHS Committee on Pell Grants
- NASFAA joins the American Council on Education and several other organizations in writing a letter to members of the House Subcommittee on Labor, Health, and Human Services, Education to express two commonly held, significant concerns with the approach outlined in the subcommittee's proposal for the FY 2012 Labor-HHS-E...
- NASFAA Supports NPRM Changing Requirements on New Gainful Employment Programs(2)
- NASFAA supports the Department of Education’s (ED) proposed changes to the requirements related to new gainful employment programs and appreciates ED’s efforts to reduce administrative burden wherever possible, NASFAA President Justin Draeger wrote in official comments submitted on Nov. 14. Final rules published on Oct...
- NASFAA Supports NPRM Changing Requirements on New Gainful Employment Programs
- NASFAA supports the Department of Education’s (ED) proposed changes to the requirements related to new gainful employment programs and appreciates ED’s efforts to reduce administrative burden wherever possible, NASFAA President Justin Draeger wrote in official comments submitted on November 14.
- NASFAA Submits Comments to the Department of Education on Draft 2012-13 FAFSA
- NASFAA submitted its letter on the 2012-13 draft paper FAFSA to the Department of Education Monday, Oct. 17, 2011, after soliciting and reviewing copies of members' comments and incorporating them into NASFAA's official comments. NASFAA thanks members who submitted copies of their comments to us. Your careful review of...
- NASFAA Joins Higher Education Groups Opposing Proposed Cuts to Minority Serving Institutions
- NASFAA joined more than 30 other higher education organizations signing a letter to urge Congress to reject a proposal in the House's fiscal year (FY) 2012 draft spending bill that would eliminate 41 percent of all federal funding for Minority Serving Institutions (MSIs).
- NASFAA Submits Comments to the Advisory Committee on Student Financial Assistance on its Higher Education Regulations Study (HERS)
- NASFAA commends the Advisory Committee for soliciting comment regarding higher education regulations from practicing financial aid administrators through the Higher Education Regulations Study (HERS). The fact that the topic of burdensome regulations has been a recurring issue over many years is indicative of the detri...
- Statement on House FY 2012 Education Budget Proposal
- NASFAA President Justin Draeger issued the following statement concerning the House Appropriations Subcommittee's draft Labor, Health and Human Services, and Education spending bill for fiscal year (FY) 2012
- NASFAA Submits Letter to the Joint Committee on Deficit Reduction
- NASFAA submitted its comments to the Joint Committee on Deficit Reduction as the committee negotiates a deficit reduction plan that can gain support in both chambers of Congress. NASFAA asked that the committee consider the vital role of the federal student aid programs to our country’s welfare and take efforts to shie...
- The Award Letter: A Model Concept
- NASFAA submitted these recommendations to improve financial aid award letters to the U.S. Department of Education. A tool for institutions to evaluate their award letters and for students and parents to evaluate award letters is included.
- NASFAA Statement on FY2009 Cohort Default Rates
- NASFAA President Justin Draeger's statement on the fiscal year (FY) 2009 cohort default rate (CDR) that grew to 8.8 percent, a 25 percent increase from the FY2008 CDR of 7 percent.
- NASFAA Submits Comments on Financial Aid Award Letters
- In response to the Department of Education’s request for comments on ways to improve financial aid award letters, NASFAA submitted its suggestions for a financial aid award letter model and best practices. In its comments, NASFAA states that standardization should apply primarily to definitions and terminology rather t...
- NASFAA President Responds to Report with Private Education Loan Counseling Recommendations
- NASFAA President Justin Draeger issued the following statement in response to Critical Choices: How Colleges Can Help Students and Families Make Better Decisions about Private Loans, a report from the Project on Student Debt at The Institute for College Access Success (TICAS).
- NASFAA Highlights Advocacy Principles Amid Talks of Financial Aid Cuts
- Growing concern over cuts to the Pell Grant program has many in the higher education community examining ways to modify the program to mitigate cost and dissuade Congress from reducing the maximum award. In its advocacy efforts, and in evaluating any potential changes to student aid programs or funding, NASFAA adheres ...
- NASFAA Justin Draeger President DREAM Act Statement for the Senate Subcommittee on Immigration, Refugees and Border Security
- NASFAA President Justin Draeger submitted this statement in support of the DREAM Act for the Senate Subcommittee on Immigration, Refugees and Border Security's June 28 hearing.
- NASFAA Signs Onto Letter to Block State Authorization and Definition of Credit Hour
- NASFAA joined several other higher education associations in signing onto a letter supporting legislation that would halt the Department of Education's regulations on state authorization and the definition of a credit hour.
- NASFAA Supports Private Student Loan Bankruptcy Fairness Act of 2011
- Coalition letter to the Honorable Steve Cohen in support of the Private Student Loan Bankruptcy Fairness Act of 2011.
- Higher Education Associations Urge ED to Reconsider Proposed FERPA Regulations
- NASFAA joined 30 higher education associations to urge the U.S. Department of Education to reconsider its proposed changes to the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) regulations.
- NASFAA Urges ED to Use 2011 Negotiated Rulemaking to Reduce Regulatory Burden
- NASFAA suggested several ways to streamline financial aid administration to reduce administrative and regulatory burdens in a letter to Education Secretary Arne Duncan in response to the Department of Education’s (ED) request for issues to discuss during the latest round of negotiated rulemaking sessions.
- NASFAA Urges House to Oppose FY2012 Budget Resolution
- NASFAA urges representatives to oppose the FY2012 budget resolution that includes dramatic cuts to the Pell Grant program.
- Student Aid Alliance FY 2012 Budget Request
- The Student Aid Alliance, a coalition of organizations representing millions of students, parents, colleges and universities, urges Congress to restore funding for student aid programs in the FY 2012 budget.
- Advocacy Update
- Track the issues that NASFAA is focusing its advocacy efforts on and how successful our advocacy has been.
- NASFAA Letter Thanks ED for Promoting the Interests of Financial Aid Administrators
- NASFAA Chair Laurie Wolf and President Justin Draeger note that the Department of Education's recent communication to college presidents will highlight the challenges financial aid administrators face.
- NASFAA Submits List of Burdensome Title IV Regulations to the Advisory Committee on Student Financial Assistance
- NASFAA submitted a package of burdensome, duplicative, and unnecessary Title IV regulations to the Advisory Committee on Student Financial Assistance.